Full Menu
Every Andy’s treat is made with fresh frozen custard — churned in-store, all day long. Browse the full menu, from seasonal treats and Concretes to shakes, sundaes, and more.

Seasonal Treats

Monster Mash Jackhammer
You're going to love this monstrously sweet Halloween flash treat. We start with our vanilla frozen custard for the base, then blend it with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups® and Reese's Pieces®, then fill it down the center with crème caramel. It's a graveyard smash so you better enjoy it fast because it's only here for a frightfully short time.

Pecan Caramel Apple
Caramel hand-rolled in pecans.

Reese’s® Pieces Caramel Apple
Caramel hand-rolled in Reese’s® Pieces

Classic Caramel Apple
Dipped in old-fashioned caramel

S'mores Jackhammer
Available for a limited time this fall.

Pumpkin Pie Quart
A take-home quart of vanilla frozen custard blended with pumpkin pie.

Pumpkin Pie Concrete
Vanilla frozen custard blended with a whole slice of pumpkin pie.
Concretes & Jackhammers

Build Your Own Jackhammer™
We take your favorite one-topping concrete and fill the center with another drizzly topping of your choice. Whether you go classic or creative, the result is a custom treat made just for you. Every bite is a flavor-packed surprise.

Build Your Own Concrete
Make a concrete of your own creation. Start with our creamy vanilla or chocolate frozen custard as your base. Pick your favorite toppings and we'll blend them right in, creating a treat that's totally customized to your taste. Whether you stick with a classic combo or try something new, the result is a concrete that's totally you. The possibilities are endless.

Monster Mash Jackhammer
You're going to love this monstrously sweet Halloween flash treat. We start with our vanilla frozen custard for the base, then blend it with Reese's Peanut Butter Cups® and Reese's Pieces®, then fill it down the center with crème caramel. It's a graveyard smash so you better enjoy it fast because it's only here for a frightfully short time.

S'mores Jackhammer
Available for a limited time this fall.

Pumpkin Pie Concrete
Vanilla frozen custard blended with a whole slice of pumpkin pie.

The Jackhammer (Custom)
We take your favorite Andy's concrete and fill the center with the drizzly topping of your choice.

Almond Delight Concrete
Andy's frozen custard blended with melted chocolate chip, roasted almonds, and toasted coconut.

German Chocolate Concrete
Andy's chocolate frozen custard blended with brownie pieces, crème caramel, and toasted coconut.

Pretzel Caramel Crunch Concrete
Andy's frozen custard blended with pretzel pieces and crème caramel.

The Jackhammer
A favorite concrete filled through the center with a topping of your choice.

Rico Suave Jackhammer
Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with roasted pecans and Oreos®, with a center filled with hot fudge.

James Brownie Funky Jackhammer
Andy’s frozen custard blended with creamy peanut butter and brownies, then filled with hot fudge.

Cherry Bash Concrete
Andy's frozen custard blended with chocolate syrup, maraschino cherries, Heath® Bar and almonds.

Choc-O-Rocko Concrete
Andy's chocolate frozen custard, roasted almonds and marshmallow crème.

Strawberry and Oreo® Concrete
Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with delicious strawberries and Oreo®.

Jitterbug Concrete
Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with espresso, Heath® Bar and almonds.

Mint Chip Concrete
Andy’s frozen custard blended with mint syrup and melted chocolate chip.

Butter Pecan Concrete
Andy’s frozen custard blended with butterscotch and roasted pecans.

Snowmonster Concrete
Andy’s frozen custard blended with strawberries and melted chocolate chip.

Ooey Gooey Concrete
Andy's frozen custard blended with Heath® Bar, crème caramel and almonds.

Triple Chocolate Concrete
Andy's chocolate frozen custard blended with chocolate chip cookie dough and melted chocolate chip.

BootDaddy Concrete
Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with Oreo®, crème caramel and hot fudge.
Sundaes

Andy's Kids' Sundae
Kid-sized scoop of vanilla frozen custard with choice of of classic topping

Andy's Turtle Split
Andy’s frozen custard and a whole banana covered with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

Andy's Banana Split
Andy’s frozen custard and a whole banana covered with delicious strawberries, marshmallow crème, crushed nuts, and topped with a cherry.

Stolen Brownie Sundae
Andy’s frozen custard and homemade brownie covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

Andy's Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans
Andy’s frozen custard covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

The Original Straw-Ana Sundae
Andy’s frozen custard covered with delicious strawberries and sliced bananas.

Tin Roof Sundae
Andy's frozen custard covered with chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts.

Andy's Ozark Turtle Sundae
Andy’s frozen custard covered with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.
Cups & Cones

Mixed Up Cup
Chocolate and Vanilla frozen custard in a small, medium, or large cup.

Vanilla Cup
Vanilla frozen custard in a small, medium, or large cup.

Vanilla Cone
Vanilla frozen custard on a small, medium, large or jumbo cone.

Chocolate Cone
Chocolate frozen custard on a small, medium, large or jumbo cone.
Drinks

Vanilla Fudge Yummy Latte
Vanilla frozen custard blended with espresso and fudge poured over ice.

Chocolate Fudge Yummy Latte
Chocolate frozen custard blended espresso and fudge poured over ice.

Vanilla Caramel Yummy Latte
Vanilla frozen custard blended with espresso and hot crème caramel poured over ice.

Chocolate Caramel Yummy Latte
Chocolate frozen custard blended with espresso and hot crème caramel poured over ice.

Bottled Sprecher™ Cream Soda
Fire brewed bottled cream soda made with pure honey.

Bottled Sprecher™ Root Beer
Fire brewed bottled craft root beer made with pure honey.

Root Beer Float
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with Sprecher® fire-brewed craft root beer.

Strawberry Old-Fashioned Soda
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with seltzer and strawberry syrup.

Raspberry Old-Fashioned Soda
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with seltzer and raspberry syrup.

Key Lime Old-Fashioned Soda
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with seltzer and key lime syrup.

Chocolate Old-Fashioned Soda
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with seltzer and chocolate syrup.

Dr Pepper Yummy Soda
Vanilla frozen custard blended with Dr Pepper® and marshmallow crème.

Cherry Limeade Yummy Soda
Vanilla frozen custard blended with Sprite®, cherries, and key lime syrup.

Cherry Coke Yummy Soda
Vanilla frozen custard blended with Coca-Cola®, cherries, and cherry syrup.

Butterscotch Brew Yummy Soda
Vanilla frozen custard with Sprecher® cream soda and rich butterscotch syrup.

Yummy Latte
Vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with espresso, ice, and caramel or fudge.

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Available in sweet or unsweet tea with or without raspberry, cherry, or strawberry syrup.

Soft Drinks
Choose from Coke®, Diet Coke® or Sprite®.

Sprecher Soda
Brewed in Milwaukee and pulled from a tap, choose from Root Beer or Cream Soda.

Cream Soda Float
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with Sprecher™ fire-brewed cream soda.

Old-Fashioned Sodas
Frozen custard, flavored syrup, and seltzer served soda-fountain style.
Shakes, Malts & Freezes

Double Double Malt
Andy's frozen custard blended with chocolate syrup and double malt powder.

Birthday Cake Shakes
Vanilla frozen custard blended with cheesecake bites and colorful sprinkles.

Strawberry Oreo® Cookie Shake
Vanilla frozen custard blended with strawberries and Oreo® cookies.

Choco Express Shake
Chocolate frozen custard blended with espresso and crème caramel.

Root Beer Freeze
Vanilla frozen custard blended with Sprecher® craft root beer.

Cream Soda Freeze
Vanilla frozen custard blended with Sprecher® cream soda.

Root Beer Float
Andy’s vanilla frozen custard with Sprecher® fire-brewed craft root beer.

Zarlengo's Italian Ice
Lemon, strawberry or raspberry lemonade flavor Italian ice tube.

Old-Fashioned Freezes
Frozen custard blended with a favorite soda.

Shakes
Frozen custard blended smooth with a favorite topping.

Malts
Frozen custard blended with a favorite topping and malt powder.
Andy's Anywhere

Pecan Caramel Apple
Caramel hand-rolled in pecans.

Reese’s® Pieces Caramel Apple
Caramel hand-rolled in Reese’s® Pieces

Classic Caramel Apple
Dipped in old-fashioned caramel

Pumpkin Pie Quart
A take-home quart of vanilla frozen custard blended with pumpkin pie.

Specialty Pint Flavors
Hard-packed frozen custard blended with a rotating choice of favorite toppings and flavors.

Quarts and Pints
Hand-packed vanilla or chocolate frozen custard to enjoy later.

Quart Combo
A vanilla or chocolate quart paired with two toppings of your choice.

Pick 6™
Six hand-packed, half-pint FreezCrete™ cups of delicious hard frozen custard blended with our fan-favorite toppings and flavors.
Andy's Caramel Apples
Build your own treat with toppings.
Add your favorite toppings to Concretes, Jackhammers™, sundaes, shakes, and malts. The result is a custom treat made just for you.
