Full Menu

The treats featured here are available year-round. We can also make numerous other creations based on your preferences with either vanilla OR chocolate frozen custard. Our available toppings that you can mix-and-match most any way you please can be found here: Full List of Toppings

Andy’s Ozark Turtle

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard covered with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

The Original Straw-Ana

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard covered with delicious strawberries and sliced bananas.

Butter Pecan Concrete

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with butterscotch and roasted pecans.

Triple Chocolate Concrete

Andy's chocolate frozen custard blended with chocolate chip cookie dough and melted chocolate chip.


Snowmonster Concrete

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with strawberries and melted chocolate chip. 

Mint Chip Concrete

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with mint syrup and melted chocolate chip.

The Jackhammer

We take your favorite Andy's concrete and fill the center with the topping of your choice.

James Brownie Funky Jackhammer

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with creamy peanut butter and brownies, then filled with hot fudge. 


Rico Suave Jackhammer

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with roasted pecans and Oreos, with a center filled with hot fudge.

Boot Daddy Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with Oreo, creme caramel and hot fudge.

Jitterbug Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with espresso, Heath Bar and almonds.

Strawberry and Oreo Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with delicious strawberries and Oreo.


Ooey Gooey Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with Heath Bar, creme caramel and almonds.

Choc-O-Rocko Concrete

Andy's chocolate or vanilla frozen custard blended with roasted almonds and marshmallow creme.

Tin Roof Sundae

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard covered with chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts. 

Cherry Bash Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with chocolate syrup, maraschino cherries, Heath Bar and almonds. 


Malts

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with your favorite topping and malt powder.

Shakes

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with your favorite topping,

Old-Fashioned Freezes

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with your favorite soda.

Old-Fashioned Sodas

Scoops of Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard with your choice of cherry, chocolate, raspberry, strawberry, or key lime flavored syrup combined with seltzer.


Floats

Scoops of Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard with your favorite soda poured over the top.

Zarlengo’s Italian Ice

Lemon, strawberry, or raspberry lemonade flavor Italian ice tube.

Andy’s Banana Split

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and a whole banana covered with delicious strawberries, marshmallow crème, crushed nuts, and topped with a cherry. 

Turtle Split

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and a whole banana covered with hot fudge, crème caramel, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.


Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

Stolen Brownie Sundae

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and homemade brownie covered with hot fudge, roasted pecans, and topped with a cherry.

Old-Fashioned Sprecher Soda

Root Beer or Cream Soda on Tap, Brewed in Milwaukee!

Bottled Sprecher Soda

Root Beer, Cream Soda, or Orange Dream.


Soft Drinks

Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, or Orange Soda

Fresh Brewed Iced Tea

Sweet, Unsweet, or Raspberry.

Specialty Pints

Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, chocolate chip cookie dough, mint chocolate chip, Bordeaux cherry chip, hot fudge brownie, or butter pecan.

Andy’s Frozen Custard Bar

Hand dipped in milk chocolate or dark chocolate and available in vanilla, salted caramel, chocolate, mint, or coffee flavors.


Seasonal Treats

We offer these treats on a seasonal, "limited time only" basis. Supplies are limited, so be sure to get your favorite when it's in season!


Currently Serving!

Pumpkin Pie Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with a slice of fresh-baked pumpkin pie

Available in late October

“Words Can’t Describe It” Apple Pie Sundae

Delicious apple pie topped with Andy's vanilla frozen custard.

Available in late October

Available in late October

“Words Can’t Describe It” Apple Pie Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with apple pie.

Available in late November

Candy Cane Concrete

Andy's vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with peppermint candy pieces


Available in late November

Andy Nog Shake 

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with egg nog.

Available mid-January

Cookie Casanova Sundae

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard and a chocolate chip cookie covered with crème caramel, almonds, and topped with a cherry.

Available in early February

Thin Mint Concrete

Andy’s vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with thin mint cookies.

Available in late April

Blueberry Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with fresh blueberries.


Available in late April

Available in late April

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

Grandma Elaine’s homemade shortcake covered with Andy's vanilla frozen custard, and topped with delicious strawberries.

Available in early June

Available in early June

Blackberry Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with fresh blackberries.

Available in mid-July

Key Lime Pie Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with a slice of key lime pie.

Available in mid-July

Peach Concrete

Andy's vanilla frozen custard blended with fresh peaches.